Nestled in the heart of the Rocky Mountains, an unexpected encounter sparked a question: Are Mexican Ducks venturing north, expanding their territory into Colorado and the wider Interior West of the U.S.? Or have these elusive waterfowl always been present, simply overlooked amidst the familiar Mallard flocks? This question arose one warm August evening in Colorado, as a birder, searching for post-storm migrants, stumbled upon an anomaly at a beaver pond. Among a group of Mallards, a duck with distinct features emerged: a dark brown body, turquoise speculum, and brown tail – a Mexican Duck.
This sighting, remarkable for its unconventional location at over 9,000 feet, was not an isolated incident. It marked the second Mexican Duck observed in Colorado’s high country in recent weeks, preceded by another male in the Arkansas River Valley and a sighting at a residential pond further north. Earlier in the spring, a female with young had also been spotted along the Front Range. These encounters ignited a compelling thought: Could the Mexican Duck, a denizen of the Southwest, be undergoing a significant range expansion, or have they been quietly inhabiting these regions, undetected for years?
An adult male Mexican Duck stands out from a molting male Mallard in a Colorado pond, raising questions about the species’ distribution and potential range expansion.
The Enigmatic Range of the Mexican Duck
The excitement surrounding these Colorado sightings stems from the Mexican Duck‘s limited and somewhat obscure distribution within the ABA Area. Their core habitat lies in central and northern Mexico, where they thrive in lakes, marshes, rivers, and even agricultural lands. Within the U.S., their presence is primarily noted from western Texas through Arizona and into the southeastern corner of California. While some may wander into the southern Rockies, their occurrence in these northern areas is generally considered minimal. When found in the U.S., Mexican Ducks are often sparsely distributed and face concerns about genetic purity due to hybridization.
In Colorado, situated at the northern periphery of their known range, the Mexican Duck is typically classified as a vagrant species. Most reported sightings occur during March and April, largely concentrated in the Denver region, a hotspot for birding activity. Records elsewhere in Colorado are scarce, with a slightly higher concentration in the San Luis Valley, bordering New Mexico and within the Rio Grande drainage. However, the recent summer encounters in the mountains, outside the typical spring migration window, challenge this perception. This raises the possibility that the Mexican Duck population in Colorado, and potentially beyond, is more substantial and persistent than previously recognized. Is the Mexican Duck truly increasing its range in Colorado, or has its presence simply been underestimated?
Identification Challenges: Distinguishing the Mexican Duck from its Look-Alikes
The Mexican Duck often evokes images of a cryptic, dark, Mallard-like bird inhabiting the southern latitudes. Indeed, many aspects of its biology remain shrouded in ambiguity. Taxonomically, it has been debated whether it is a subspecies of the Mallard or a distinct species, adding to the identification complexity. This challenge is further compounded by the frequent occurrence of hybrids, making accurate identification a daunting task, comparable to identifying Empidonax flycatchers or gulls. Along with other “brown Mallards” in the ABA Area—the Mottled Duck, Hawaiian Duck, and American Black Duck—the Mexican Duck presents a significant identification hurdle for birders.
Successful Mexican Duck spotting often involves carefully scanning flocks of Mallards, ideally those numbering a dozen or more. The Mexican Ducks recently observed in Colorado, excluding the female with young, were all found within larger waterfowl groups. These aggregations need not be at vast reservoirs; Mexican Ducks are frequently reported at smaller bodies of water like local duck ponds or water treatment plants, and may even favor these less expansive habitats. Due to their general scarcity in the U.S., Mexican Ducks are rarely seen in large groups, except in southern Arizona and New Mexico, where they occasionally gather in homogenous flocks. For instance, Sweetwater Wetlands Park in Tucson can see Mexican Ducks outnumbering Mallards during winter.
Adult male Mexican Ducks, pictured in Arizona, exhibit the key characteristics for identification in their typical range.
Delving into Taxonomy and the Mallard Complex
The Mexican Duck, scientifically known as Anas [platyrhynchos] diazi, is currently classified as a subspecies of the Mallard by both the American Ornithological Society and the ABA. However, a significant number of ornithologists advocate for its recognition as a full species. This article aims to explore the natural history and field identification of this often-misunderstood member of the ABA Area’s birdlife. The adult male Mexican Duck in basic (breeding) plumage is often initially recognized by its “female Mallard” plumage coupled with a “male Mallard” bill. Males in alternate (eclipse) plumage pose a greater challenge, and females and hybrids are notoriously difficult to identify.
The Mallard super-species complex in the ABA Area comprises five species: Mallard, American Black Duck, Mottled Duck, Hawaiian Duck, and Mexican Duck. Mallards are the most widespread, found across the region in virtually all aquatic environments, and are known to readily hybridize with other waterfowl. Historically, Mallards were considered the closest relatives of Mexican Ducks, but recent genetic studies suggest a closer relationship between Mottled Ducks and Mexican Ducks. The influx of Mallard genes poses a threat to the genetic integrity of certain species, particularly Mexican and Hawaiian ducks, which have smaller, more vulnerable populations. Concerns exist that gene flow from Mallards could lead to a loss of genetic “purity” in the Mexican Duck. However, central Mexico likely still harbors substantial populations of relatively pure Mexican Ducks, with one study estimating at least 55,000 in the highlands alone. Even the American Black Duck, with a larger range, has faced concerns about introgressive hybridization, although recent research re-evaluates this threat.
Despite visible plumage differences between Mallards, Mexican Ducks, and American Black Ducks, genetic distinctions are surprisingly subtle. This likely reflects extensive hybridization within the super-species complex and incomplete lineage sorting, contributing to phylogenetic ambiguity. The genetic similarity suggests an adaptive radiation primarily affecting plumage rather than broader genetic diversity. This complex evolutionary history contributes to the ongoing confusion among scientists and birders and fuels the debate surrounding Mexican Duck classification.
Female Mallards illustrate the plumage variability within the species, highlighting the need for careful observation when differentiating them from Mexican Ducks.
Within the Mallard superspecies complex, males and females of the familiar Mallard exhibit striking differences in breeding plumage. However, in the other four species (Mexican, Mottled, Hawaiian, and American Black ducks), adult males retain a more “female-like” plumage throughout the year. This means that any “female-like” duck within this group warrants a closer inspection – it might be more than just a Mallard! Female Mallards, shown here, display typical variations in color and pattern. Key identification marks include an orangey bill with black markings, a blue speculum with broad white borders, and a predominantly white tail.
Field Identification: Key Features to Look For
Since 1983, the Mexican Duck has been classified as a subspecies of the Mallard. This classification has, unfortunately, led to a degree of neglect by field birders. Currently, the American Ornithological Society (AOS) maintains this subspecies status due to a broad hybridization zone and a perceived lack of conclusive genetic evidence. Conversely, the eBird/Clements Checklist elevated the Mexican Duck to species status in 2018, citing genetic findings within the Mallard complex. Research by Philip Lavretsky and colleagues (2014) indicates that Mexican Ducks began diverging from Mallards approximately 325,000 years ago, significantly longer than the divergence of American Black Ducks around 180,000 years ago. Furthermore, Mexican Ducks do not appear to hybridize with Mallards more extensively than other taxa within this complex. This contrasting taxonomic treatment underscores the ongoing uncertainty surrounding the Mexican Duck‘s status. Future re-evaluations of its classification will likely rely on genetic analyses and a deeper understanding of its natural history.
Besides taxonomic ambiguity, the difficulty in field identification is a major reason why birders may shy away from the Mexican Duck. In the continental U.S., three primary species are frequently confused with the Mexican Duck: Mottled Duck, American Black Duck, and Mallard. All are prone to vagrancy, and birds outside their typical ranges can occur within Mexican Duck territory, and vice versa. All members of this super-species complex share similar size and structure, and their vocalizations are also very alike.
Distinguishing from Mallards
The Mallard serves as the baseline for identification challenges, primarily due to its overwhelming abundance across the Southwest. Especially during summer, differentiating Mexican Ducks from male Mallards can seem incredibly difficult. However, with focused observation and knowledge of key features, they can be reliably distinguished from their ubiquitous relatives.
Compared to Mallards, the male Mexican Duck exhibits a significantly darker overall plumage, with a distinct contrast between the breast and a paler, tan-colored throat. The head displays a dark crown and eye-line, which noticeably stands out against the pale face. Summer Mallards often have blotchy facial patterns and a less defined eye-line. Bill coloration in male Mexican Ducks is variable, ranging from yellow to olive-green, but often appears more muted than the bright yellow bill of a male Mallard. Another crucial feature is the speculum, which tends to be more turquoise blue than the purplish hue often seen in Mallards, though this can be influenced by lighting conditions. The white borders of the speculum are thinner in pure Mexican Ducks, whereas Mallards exhibit noticeably thicker white edges.
An adult female Mexican Duck in Colorado showcases the subtle field marks that differentiate females from Mallards, including bill coloration and tail pattern.
Perhaps the most reliable distinguishing feature is the color of the tail and under-tail coverts. In all Mexican Ducks (male and female), the tail is predominantly brown, as are the undertail coverts. In contrast, Mallards have a mostly white tail with variable but limited brown markings. This is particularly helpful during summer when male Mallards may more closely resemble Mexican Ducks in plumage. While separating male Mexican Ducks and Mallards can be relatively straightforward, differentiating females of the two species is considerably more challenging.
Many female Mexican Ducks are virtually indistinguishable from female Mallards, and female hybrids are even less understood due to identification complexities. However, the same core features apply to females as to males: darker plumage, a turquoise speculum with narrow white edging, and brown tail and under-tail coverts. Female Mexican Ducks consistently show body plumage that is noticeably darker than typical Mallards. Similar to males, a distinct demarcation exists between the dark brown breast and a paler, dusky throat. The facial pattern also tends to be more pronounced. While these characteristics can contribute to identification, there is significant overlap with Mallards.
The key identifying feature is the mottled brown tail, which, in a pure Mexican Duck, lacks white, except for pale edging on the tail sides in some worn individuals. Furthermore, there should be no hint of upturned tail feathers, a characteristic of male Mallards. The under-tail coverts should also be uniformly dark or dusky, rather than speckled brown and white. The bill of a female Mexican Duck is highly variable, ranging from bright orange to a duskier orange-yellow; however, most retain at least a hint of a black saddle. Although overlap exists, the bill of a female Mexican Duck is generally more consistently orange and exhibits less extensive black splotching compared to a female Mallard. For confident identification, especially of females, a combination of these features should be observed, requiring close views, careful examination, and ideally, photographic documentation.
Distinguishing from Mottled and American Black Ducks
Although the core ranges of Mottled and Mexican ducks only overlap in a small area of south Texas, differentiating between them (and their hybrids!) may be necessary. Adult male Mottled Ducks possess a small but diagnostic black spot at the gape, which is absent in Mexican Ducks. Mottled Ducks also tend to have a bright yellow bill, while Mexican Duck bills are often a duller olive-yellow. The face of a Mottled Duck is a clean, unmarked buffy, whereas the Mexican Duck‘s face appears duskier due to fine black feathering. Additionally, the eye-line of a male Mottled Duck is noticeably shorter than in other members of the Mallard complex. Another key feature of pure Mottled Ducks is the lack of any white edging on the speculum, while all Mexican Ducks have some degree of white edging. Female Mottled Ducks share similar identification challenges with their Mexican Duck counterparts. The bill color in female Mottled Ducks is more reliably solid orange, the face is a brighter, unmarked buffy, the eye-line is shorter, and the speculum lacks white edging. Female Mottled Ducks also possess the distinctive dark gape spot seen in males.
American Black Ducks, primarily found in the Northeast, do not naturally overlap in range with Mexican Ducks, but vagrant individuals could create identification challenges. This is particularly true given occasional releases of American Black Ducks outside their native range.
American Black Ducks of both sexes can usually be distinguished from Mexican Ducks based on coloration alone. American Black Ducks are very dark, approaching blackish, whereas Mexican Ducks exhibit richer, browner tones. Furthermore, the scapulars and back of Mexican Ducks have internal markings, which are absent in American Black Ducks. Pure American Black Ducks also lack any white edging on the speculum. Females often have dull olive or dusky bills, rather than the brighter orange-yellow bills typical of Mexican Ducks. American Black Duck x Mallard hybrids often retain blackish body plumage, although they can be variable and resemble Mallard x Mexican Duck hybrids.
Hybrids and the Complexity of Identification
Despite growing knowledge, Mexican Duck identification remains complex. Just as confidence builds, encountering a hybrid or a backcross individual can introduce doubt. Similar to how birders in the Pacific Northwest assume many Glaucous-winged Gulls are not pure, one might question whether most Mexican Ducks in the U.S. carry some Mallard genes. That being said, phenotypically pure birds do exist, especially in southern Arizona and New Mexico. Mexican Duck x Mallard hybrids often display a combination of white in the tail or curled tail feathers and green on the head. Males frequently exhibit a reddish breast, reminiscent of Mallards, rather than the dark brown breast of a pure Mexican Duck. These hybrids are highly variable; some, like F2 and F3 backcrosses, closely resemble male Mallards, except for some brown on the head or flanks. Others may strongly resemble pure Mexican Ducks but have some white in the tail feathers. Some individuals simply defy definitive identification.
A female Mexican Duck with her offspring, a Mexican Duck x Mallard hybrid, illustrates the challenges of identifying hybrids, particularly in younger birds.
First-generation adult male hybrids in basic (breeding) plumage, like the bird in the foreground of the image below, are often identifiable by their blend of Mexican Duck and Mallard traits. Backcross males and hybrid females of any generation are significantly more challenging, and the existence of intersex individuals (often older females) further complicates identification.
In cases of uncertainty, reporting birds as “Mallard/ Mexican Duck” or even “duck sp.” is a prudent approach. Even expert opinions can vary, as illustrated by one bird initially identified as a Mallard x Mexican Duck hybrid, which was subsequently debated as possibly an American Black Duck x Mallard, then Mallard x Mexican Duck, and even Mexican x Mottled. Without genetic testing, some birds will remain unidentifiable.
An intriguing factor in Mexican Duck identification is the phenomenon of intersex Mallards. As waterfowl mature, plumage features can shift to resemble the opposite sex, potentially linked to estrogen imbalances or ovarian issues. In intersex Mallards, females may gradually develop masculine traits, such as green head plumage, leading to confusion with hybrids, especially Mallard x Mexican Duck, Mallard x Gadwall, and Mallard x American Black Duck. However, intersex birds typically retain a female-like bill (orange with a black saddle), while hybrids often have the yellow or dusky bills of males.
In Colorado, numerous birds have been observed that resemble potential Mexican Ducks, particularly females exhibiting traits like dark body plumage and a turquoise speculum. Many intermediate birds defy certain identification, and caution is warranted north of their typical range, where hybridization levels are less known. In the Southwest, it seems almost every sizable Mallard flock may contain a Mexican Duck or hybrid. While Mexican Duck identification can be intricate, it is a worthwhile endeavor for both birders and the conservation of this species. The Mexican Duck is vulnerable due to Mallard introgression and a limited range, a situation likely exacerbated by climate change. By diligently reporting Mexican Duck observations, birders contribute valuable data for scientists to better understand and conserve this enigmatic species.
References
Bird Hybrids. 2015. Intersex birds (and their confusion with hybrids), in: D. Appleton, admin., Bird Hybrids: A Collaborative Project to Improve Understanding of Bird Hybrids (tinyurl.com/bird-hybrids).
Clements Checklist. 2018. Updates and corrections— August 2018. (tinyurl.com/Clements- 2018-update). Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca.
Floyd, A., and T. Floyd. 2017. The Mexican Duck in Colorado: Status, distribution, and field identification [abstract]. Presentation to Western Field Ornithologists (tinyurl.com/Floyd-Floyd-MeDu).
Lavretsky, P., B. E. Hernández-Baños, and J. L. Peters. 2014. Rapid radiation and hybridization contribute to weak differentiation and hinder phylogenetic inferences in the New World Mallard complex (Anas spp.). Auk 131: 524–538.
Lavretsky, P., N. R. McInerney, J. E. Mohl, J. I. Brown, H. F. James, K. G. McCracken, and R. C. Fleischer. 2019. Assessing changes in genomic divergence following a century of human-mediated secondary contact among wild and captive- bred ducks. Molecular Ecology 28: 1–18.
Ottenburghs, J. 2019. Genetic study of the Mallard complex reveals extensive hybridization with little recent gene flow. Avian Hybrids (tinyurl.com/Mallard-genetics).
Leukering, T., and S. G. Mlodinow. 2012. The Mexican Duck in Colorado: Identification and occurrence. Colorado Birds 46: 296–308.
Scott, N. J., and R. P. Reynolds. 1984. Phenotypic variation of the Mexican Duck (Anas platyrhynchos diazi) in Mexico. Condor 86: 266–274.
Sibley, D. A. 2011. Intergradation between Mexican Duck and Mallard in Arizona. Sibley Guides (tinyurl.com/Sibley-MeDu).
Stiver, H. 2009. Intersex Mallard. Nature Notes (tinyurl.com/Intersex-Mallard).
Tanaka, T., and P. Pyle. 2018. An odd duck: Sex, age, and Wood Ducks. Birding 50 (5): 56–59.
